A tenant is suing a serious New York Metropolis landlord for $60 million, claiming they illegally evicted him after which re-rented his condo — along with his stuff nonetheless inside — regardless of an ongoing authorized battle.
Justin Collins claims he was pressured out of his $3,500-a-month one-bedroom condo at 1264 Lexington Ave. on the Higher East Aspect due to “uninhabitable” and harmful situations, together with a carbon monoxide leak when his beloved pooch was dwelling alone for hours.
He has been on lease strike — and in litigation — since 2023.
However earlier than a choose may rule whether or not he owes lease, or if he’s owed a rent-stabilized lease, the Moinian Group noticed an opportunity to double-dip and rented the unit out whereas additionally amassing over $34,000 from his rental insurer, the swimsuit claims.
That constitutes an unlawful eviction, his $60 million swimsuit claims.
“For me, that is about them following the legislation,” mentioned Collins, who works in consulting and grew up with a police chief as a father. “That’s it. And to shine a light-weight on the systemic abuse.”
Collins had even left a few of his belongings within the condo, like a pc monitor and a pair of window-unit air conditioners, which really seem within the itemizing pictures, he mentioned.
The present resident within the condo didn’t reply the door when a Publish reporter knocked Tuesday.
“Homeowners wrongfully circumvented New York Metropolis and New York State Legislation which requires a landlord to evict a tenant in court docket and in doing so, didn’t observe correct process,” in response to the lawsuit.
The seven-story 24-unit constructing at 1264 Lexington Ave. has confronted years of points and litigation.
The constructing has obtained practically 400 housing complaints and nearly $150,000 in fines and emergency restore payments over the previous few years, information present.
One longtime tenant of 34 years mentioned she was “shocked, however I’m not stunned.”
“It’s a part of a sample,” mentioned Carletta Downs, 66. “I’m shocked that they thought they might get away with it, however I’m not stunned that they did it.”
Moinian touts itself as “one of many largest privately held actual property funding firms on this planet with a portfolio in extra of 20 million sq. toes,” in response to their web site.
Collins mentioned his issues started proper when he moved in April 2023, as he tried to kind out why his condo had no energy, and why Con-Ed had no file of his unit.
That’s as a result of his unit — together with two others — had been illegally created by splitting bigger rent-stabilized flats, with each serviced from the identical electrical panel, in response to court docket paperwork and metropolis information. Buildings officers mentioned current work has “legalized” the items, although they nonetheless lack a ultimate certificates of occupancy.
The melange of hazards additionally included damaged flooring, black mould and a number of carbon monoxide leaks, Collins mentioned.
Moinian dismissed his issues, Collins claimed, so he went on a lease strike that September and was sued months later for nonpayment.
After his canine was dwelling alone for hours throughout a carbon monoxide leak in early 2024 — when firefighters ultimately broke down his door — he began sleeping at his associate’s condo.
“I used to be in fixed worry as a result of I didn’t know what I used to be going to come back dwelling to, if my canine was going to be protected,” he mentioned.
When Collins left, Moinian claimed that he deserted his lease.
Collins’s lawyer, Leon Behar, mentioned the condo is definitely lease stabilized because it was cleaved from a stabilized unit — which grants tenants an automated lease renewal.
Weeks after Monian first filed a nonpayment swimsuit in opposition to Collins, the property big collected a $34,000 declare from his renter’s insurance coverage on the unadjudicated debt, a transfer the swimsuit calls “blatantly mendacity to the insurance coverage suppliers in order that they could possibly be paid.”
Moinian’s lawyer, Matthew Zwiren, informed The Publish that they “sit up for vigorously defending in opposition to these claims in court docket.”
Corey Friedman, 28, lives on Collins’ flooring and informed The Publish on Tuesday that he hasn’t paid lease since March 2022 — and that he’s been trapped within the “demise lure” elevator a dozen instances.
He thinks the $60 million quantity would possibly lastly get Moinian’s consideration.
“We maintain making an attempt to determine, what’s their endgame?” Friedman mentioned. “Why wouldn’t they wish to simply guarantee that we are able to dwell right here safely, that we are able to have an elevator that works, that we are able to have a constructing that’s not falling aside?”
Supply hyperlink
