A chilly breeze passes alongside the shore of Lake Contonga, 4,400 metres up within the Peruvian Andes. Julio Rimac Damian, from the close by village of Challhuayaco, factors to the mud below his ft. “All this was once coated with water,” he says.
A canal working from the lake that’s supposed to hold water to lowland villages has additionally run dry. Damian says the water started to vanish two years in the past when a mining firm began exploratory drilling in Peru’s highlands.
“This can be a tragedy for us,” Damian says. “We rely on these waters.”
Behind Lake Contonga lies one of many greatest zinc mines on the earth: Antamina. The open-pit mine, which additionally produces copper, silver, lead and molybdenum, is operated by a multinational company owned by the massive mining corporations BHP Billiton, Glencore and Teck Assets in addition to the Japanese conglomerate Mitsubishi. Glencore, a key shareholder based mostly in Switzerland, performs a dominant position in international mineral markets, whereas BHP is the world’s greatest miner.
Antamina has been given the go-ahead by the Peruvian authorities to increase zinc extraction within the space, though the Andean mountain ranges are labeled as extraordinarily weak to the local weather disaster by the Intergovernmental Panel on Local weather Change (IPCC).
Greater than half of Peru’s glaciers have melted over the previous 50 years because of international heating. Meltwater from the glaciers is the principle water supply for the folks of the Andes, however is already briefly provide.
Since 2014, Peru’s zinc manufacturing has elevated and the worth of exports has risen by practically 60%, in line with the ministry of vitality and mines. The nation has the world’s fourth-largest zinc reserves, historically exploited for the automotive and development industries.
Nonetheless, the brand new zinc increase is fuelled by the surge in demand for inexperienced vitality know-how. Zinc is used to supply batteries, photo voltaic panels and windmills because it protects them from corrosion. Demand for it has not too long ago soared, particularly within the wind vitality sector.
In accordance with the Worldwide Vitality Company, the inexperienced transition is driving “unprecedented progress” within the minerals market. Though zinc is just not but on the prime of the market, it’s anticipated to see one of many greatest rises amongst inexperienced minerals. In 2022, the market value of zinc hit historic highs – $4,500 a tonne (£3,650).
The World Financial institution considers zinc to be one of many most vital minerals for local weather motion and predicts demand will enhance by 200% by 2050.
Sabina Grund, on the Worldwide Zinc Affiliation (IZA), says: “The way forward for the zinc trade within the inexperienced transition appears very vivid. In Europe, we anticipate a major enhance in zinc demand.”
Peru is the world’s second-largest producer of unrefined zinc after China. In 2023, most of Peru’s zinc was exported to China, the US, South Korea and Spain.
In 2023, the Antamina mine, partly owned by Glencore, produced virtually 36% of Peru’s zinc, in line with Peruvian customs data. A lot of Europe’s zinc is refined at three massive smelters: the Glencore-owned Asturiana de Zinc smelter in northern Spain, Nyrstar in Belgium and the Swedish-owned Boliden Kokkola in Finland.
Peruvian zinc imported to Europe to supply low-carbon know-how is mined in areas already weak to the local weather disaster. In October 2023, the Peruvian congress declared a state of emergency because of drought linked to the El Niño climate fluctuation. The state of affairs was significantly dangerous within the Andes, the place zinc mining is concentrated.
Research present that mining can exacerbate the local weather disaster in glacial areas, as mud air pollution can speed up the melting of glaciers by absorbing extra warmth. In Chile, mining-waste ponds and street development have exacerbated the shrinking of glaciers.
The trade additionally makes use of massive quantities of water and specialists say mining poses the biggest danger in areas with the least water, together with Peru.
“Within the case of Antamina, the concession has been established in such a danger zone, as it’s surrounded by key water reserves,” says Karem Luque, a Peruvian biologist specialising in human and environmental well being.
“Water provides are closely affected already within the exploration stage. Drilling holes of 100-150 metres within the floor interrupts the pure programs of water that feed principal rivers.”
The zinc-mining trade might scale back its environmental affect by growing recycling, say specialists. Solely 29% of the world’s zinc is recycled, because of insufficient restoration methods due to a scarcity of financial incentives.
Mining has brought on different kinds of environmental injury and air pollution elsewhere in Peru. “We’re speaking about power publicity of native folks to completely different sorts of contaminants and poisonous substances by air, soil and water,” Luque says.
Proof of contamination may also be discovered on the Antamina zinc mine. Between 2008 and 2023, the corporate was sanctioned over 67 environmental incidents. These included exceeding permitted limits for air pollution and failing to stop leaks from wastewater ponds.
Antamina says the corporate has recognized the issues to keep away from additional environmental impacts from the mine. “Not one of the water our bodies within the San Marcos district might be affected,” the corporate’s consultant says.
The Peruvian authorities have labeled San Marcos as a high-risk space because of its excessive focus of heavy metals. Regardless that it’s the district surrounding Antamina, the supply of the heavy metals is outlined as “unknown”. In January 2024, a well being and environmental emergency was declared throughout the area and a number of other different districts.
Residents say that final 12 months the well being authorities measured concentrations of heavy metallic in water sources close to the mine. The outcomes haven’t but been printed.
Arsenic is a extremely poisonous heavy metallic launched into the setting as a by-product of zinc extraction; publicity to excessive ranges in water may cause most cancers and different ailments.
Antamina has additionally been questioned by the Áncash regional well being authorities about allegations made by the environmental organisation Natura and residents of Huarmey concerning the excessive ranges of arsenic amongst folks dwelling within the port, the place the corporate shops zinc earlier than export. The corporate says the presence of heavy metals “is just not associated to their operative processes”.
The Guardian has seen the outcomes of urine analyses of 100 residents dwelling close to the port carried out in 2023; solely two of them had been inside permitted ranges. A number of samples taken from youngsters had arsenic ranges at 10 to fifteen instances above the permitted limits.
The precise sources of contamination are “not recognized”. In September 2024, the Áncash regional authorities put ahead a plan to seek out the sources of excessive ranges of heavy metals, particularly arsenic.
Luque says transporting zinc to the port and storage services are possible sources of arsenic, as air pollution builds up within the air and soil. Antamina’s consultant says these outcomes “alone should not ample to establish the character of publicity or the supply” of arsenic, including that their copper and zinc concentrates arrive at Huarmey port “by a airtight underground pipeline and its situations are monitored in actual time”.
Peru’s Environmental Evaluation and Oversight Company (OEFA) didn’t reply to requests for remark about the way it displays heavy metallic ranges within the Huarmey port space.
Final 12 months, the EU’s company sustainability due diligence directive was adopted however the bloc has no binding mechanisms to carry corporations accountable for the environmental impacts of zinc manufacturing.
Emily Iona Stewart, who heads EU relations over transition minerals on the environmental advocacy group World Witness, says: “The present rules are broad and solely apply to the most important corporations. In addition they don’t stress corporations to make adjustments downstream within the manufacturing chain.”
Stewart says the directive wants important developments to genuinely enhance transparency and environmental practices in provide chains. At present, accountable zinc manufacturing falls below a voluntary scheme run by the London Steel Alternate (LME) and the Zinc Mark, issued by the IZA.
Being listed as an LME model requires corporations to observe a accountable sourcing coverage, which incorporates implementing the OECD due diligence steering.
Nicole Hanson, head of sustainability on the trade, says: “The LME’s final motion … is to droop or de-list the model from our authorised manufacturers listing.”
She provides: “We did must take this motion this 12 months for a lot of of our manufacturers.”
The European smelters Asturiana de Zinc and Boliden Kokkola, which imported Peruvian zinc in 2023, belong to the LME model listing. The listing solely covers smelters and refiners of zinc metallic; corporations extracting zinc ore or manufacturing completed zinc merchandise should not topic to comparable management.
Nyrstar stated it had “strong insurance policies and due-diligence practices in place” as a part of “actively pursuing” LME’s accountable sourcing practices and had been awarded the Zinc Mark for 4 of its six zinc smelters.
Mitsubishi stated Antamina met worldwide and native requirements, “considers coexistence with the native setting and communities as one in every of its prime administration priorities” and addressed points in a well timed method.
The Guardian requested 9 key European inexperienced know-how producers concerning the origin of the zinc they use in manufacturing. Solely three corporations replied, however they refused to touch upon the origin of their zinc.
In the Andean highlands, the morning solar is mirrored in a inexperienced signal that stands out within the panorama. “Antamina mining space: no trespassing or animal grazing,” it reads. Julio Rimac Damian says he doesn’t oppose mining however is disillusioned by how the corporate treats native folks and the setting.
“The corporate simply says to us that the lake is drying due to local weather change,” he says.
Elva Cotrina Espinoza, a smallholder from Challhuayaco, shares the identical view. “It’s changing into more and more tough to earn a dwelling from agriculture. Fertiliser costs are sky-high and there may be hardly sufficient water,” she says.
“We want the corporate would at the very least give us some financial assist. There’s a determined want for an irrigation canal, however the firm by no means exhibits up right here.”
Within the division of Áncash, the place the Antamina mine is situated, the poverty charge reached 25% in 2023, a 16% rise on the 12 months earlier than, and practically 68,000 folks within the area reside in excessive poverty. Many native residents are conscious that Glencore made $4.3bn revenue for its shareholders that 12 months.
“The mining revenue doesn’t find yourself with the communities,” says Damian. “As an alternative, the corporate desires to take out the final drops of our water.”
Supply hyperlink
