On 24 August, a Russian tech billionaire’s personal jet landed at Le Bourget airport, north-east of Paris, to seek out that officers of the French judicial police have been ready for him. He was duly arrested and whisked away for interrogation. 4 days later he was indicted on 12 costs, together with alleged complicity within the distribution of kid exploitation materials and drug trafficking, barred from leaving France and positioned underneath “judicial supervision”, which requires him to verify in with the gendarmes twice per week till additional discover.
The mogul in query, Pavel Durov, is a tech entrepreneur who collects nationalities the way in which others acquire air miles. In actual fact it seems that one in every of his citizenships is French, generously offered in 2021 by France’s president, Emmanuel Macron. Durov can be, it appears, a health fanatic with a punishing each day regime. “After eight hours of tracked sleep,” the Monetary Occasions reviews, “he begins the day ‘with out exception’ with 200 push-ups, 100 sit-ups and an ice bathtub. He doesn’t drink, smoke, eat sugar or meat, and saves time for meditation.” When not engaged in these demanding actions, he has additionally discovered time to father greater than 100 youngsters as a sperm donor and to rival Elon Musk as a free-speech extremist.
Media profiles of Durov recall to mind Churchill’s celebrated description of Russia as “a riddle wrapped in a thriller inside an enigma”. Durov left Russia as a result of the Fb clone he co-founded together with his brother Nikolai in 2006 led to battle with the Kremlin. He ultimately moved to the United Arab Emirates, the place he arrange Telegram, a privately held social media platform that’s nearly as mysterious as its founder.
Telegram has about 950 million common customers. It’s partly a messaging system like WhatsApp, however whereas WhatsApp caps group numbers at 1,024, Telegram permits as much as 200,000 and in that sense it’s additionally a broadcasting system like X. One-to-one communications are end-to-end encrypted provided that customers select the “secret chats” choice, which since many web customers by no means change the default settings in impact means, in response to one safety professional, “that the overwhelming majority of one-on-one Telegram conversations – and actually each single group chat – are in all probability seen on Telegram’s servers”.
Provided that, what’s puzzling is why there are such a lot of unhealthy actors on the platform. In spite of everything, rats usually abhor sunshine. However, as one critic places it: “Telegram is the closest we’ve to a popularised darkish net. Almost a billion largely common people are rubbing shoulders with criminals, hackers, terrorists and baby abusers. Regardless of the shortage of technical safety and privateness, the platform is a honeypot for these working within the shadows.” And maybe they keep as a result of Durov doesn’t imagine in content material moderation. Certainly, he has typically boasted about what a lean operation he runs. Like Musk, he doesn’t imagine in costly moderation groups. And one of many motivations believed to lie behind the French prosecution of him is the way in which his firm has refused to cooperate with regulation enforcement businesses which are investigating prison actions on the platform.
Telegram’s funds are additionally considerably mysterious. Paperwork leaked to the Monetary Occasions detailing its 2023 operations present that it misplaced $173m that 12 months. Its enterprise mannequin appears hazy, consisting of rudimentary promoting, subscriptions and – look forward to it! – the toncoin cryptocurrency. Previous to Durov’s arrest, there had been speak of an preliminary public providing, which now seems like a pipe dream.
However all of that is simply background noise masking the epochal significance of Durov’s arrest in a wider context. For the previous three many years, the democratic world has been in a funk about two challenges posed by a world dominated by tech and its company masters. The primary was the impunity apparently conferred on tech moguls by part 230 of the 1996 US Communications Decency Act, which liberated them from legal responsibility for what appeared on their platforms. The second involved the discrepancy between native legal guidelines and a world know-how that transcended frontiers.
Effectively, simply in regards to the time that Durov’s airplane was touching down in Le Bourget, a decide in a US district court docket was handing down a landmark judgment indicating that the free experience offered to companies by part 230 could also be coming to an finish. And a French authorized authority signalled to a tech overlord that whereas he may suppose he guidelines the world, France controls its personal airspace. Which is why Musk could must suppose twice about overflying Europe in future. Vive la France!
What I’m studying
Maintain that thought
A Thinker Thinks is a beautiful, quirky essay by Joseph Epstein within the London Assessment of Books on the tough artwork of considering.
after publication promotion
Authority determine
Learn The Perils of State Energy, Yascha Mounk’s transcript of his marvellous interview with the late, nice anthropologist James C Scott.
Black books
Roland Allen’s pleasurable essay Moleskine Mania: How a Pocket book Conquered the Digital Period within the Walrus seems on the unusual persistence of the black pocket book.
-
Do you’ve an opinion on the problems raised on this article? If you want to submit a letter of as much as 250 phrases to be thought-about for publication, e mail it to us at observer.letters@observer.co.uk
Supply hyperlink
