The Democratic-led state Legislature handed a invoice so as to add 12 new Civil Courtroom judgeships all through New York Metropolis to handle backlogs in circumstances — however excluded Staten Island, the most Republican borough.
Three judgeships every can be added to Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and The Bronx underneath the invoice handed by the Meeting and Senate within the closing hours of the legislative session final week.
Staten Island was excluded regardless of an enormous backlog of circumstances, the borough’s GOP lawmakers mentioned.
“The allocation is blatantly disproportionate and doesn’t adequately mirror the rising wants of our group,” state Assemblyman Michael Reilly (R-SI) mentioned.
All 4 of the elected Civil Courtroom judges on Staten Island are Republican, and it’s seemingly that with former President Donald Trump, the GOP’s presumptive 2024 presidential nominee, faring effectively on the high of the ticket, any new judges elected might be Republicans, too.
Further slots of household courtroom judges will go to Cayuga, Chenango, Cortland, Erie, Jefferson, Nassau, Rensselaer, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester counties.
One GOP lawmaker mentioned freezing essentially the most conservative borough from further judgeship reeks of partisanship.
“It’s peculiar that Staten Island, the one borough that constantly votes Republican, was excluded,” mentioned Assemblyman Michael Tannousis, additionally Staten Island’s Republican Celebration chairman.
Reilly despatched a letter to Gov. Kathy Hochul Monday urging to not signal the invoice into regulation except the Legislature provides three judgeships for Staten Island as an modification.
He famous that Staten Island, with an estimated inhabitants of 475,000, accounts for six% of the town’s inhabitants however solely get 3% of the judges.
State Sen. Brad Hoylman-Sigal (D-Manhattan), the Judiciary Committee chairman, defended the allocation of positions and emphasised that judges could be reassigned from different boroughs to Staten Island.
“I’m not naïve to counsel that politics doesn’t play a task,” he mentioned. “However I prefer to assume that the judgeships we created are for non-partisan functions.
“I’m grateful Albany handed our laws this session to answer the big backlog of circumstances by creating 28 judgeships throughout the state to be devoted to household courts throughout the state,” Hoylman-Sigal mentioned.
He mentioned lots of the metropolis judges will deal with household courtroom circumstances, noting the backlog of such circumstances is most extreme in Brooklyn, with roughly 25,000 circumstances and the Bronx, with 21,000 circumstances, adopted by Queens with 17,000 and Manhattan with 9,300 circumstances.
“Staten Island at present has 3,400 circumstances on backlog, nevertheless it’s absolutely anticipated that any of the 16 new judges we created for New York Metropolis might be moved to Staten Island household courtroom to handle the backlog there if it isn’t expeditiously cleared. These judges can actually be assigned to any borough, which is the expectation,” Hoylman-Sigal mentioned.
However Reilly mentioned Staten Island voters ought to have the correct to elect their very own judges that characterize their values, not get jurists assigned from different boroughs.
“We’re not giving the folks of Staten Island the power to elect the judges they deem match to take a seat within the borough,” mentioned Reilly.
Staten Island has just one Democratic boroughwide elected official — District Legal professional Michael McMahon.
Congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis and Borough President Vito Fossella are Republicans, as are a majority of metropolis council members and state legislators.
Supply hyperlink
