A scathing new report slams former Gov. Andrew Cuomo for botching the state’s COVID-19 response — saying he erred by bumping state well being officers out of the way in which so he may micromanage the pandemic from the manager workplace.
Cuomo made an “a major and pointless mistake.” when he ignored established well being division protocols set as much as deal with the virus and took the initiative away from native communities, in response to the 262-page report by The Olson Group, a consulting agency.
“The state had the plans however didn’t observe them as a result of the manager chamber wished to do their very own factor,” mentioned one official interviewed by the authors. “If the state had used the plans that had been accessible and written, then, sure, they’d have had the right plans in place.
“However as a substitute we had been caught with all these government orders.”
The report mentioned the Cuomo administration merely deserted preparedness plans already in place — which referred to as for the state well being division to take the lead.
For instance, the division’s long-planned system for offering community-based vaccination websites was thrown out the window, with Cuomo as a substitute dictating that “hub hospitals” would supply the photographs — regardless of not having the aptitude to take action successfully.
“The constructions developed via hard-won expertise from occasions together with 9/11 and Hurricane Sandy had been largely ignored and the state’s chief government workplace served because the central level of the response.”
“Though decisive actions had been broadly praised in the course of the early phases of the pandemic, his failure to shift to full incorporation of the state’s established establishments in coordinating the continued response operation resulted in pointless confusion at a time when New Yorkers wanted readability.”
Whereas the report raps Cuomo for alleged micromanaging, it doesn’t say if his method led to additional circumstances for deaths. The Empire State suffered 77,000 deaths in the course of the pandemic.
The report additionally chided the state’s reporting of nursing dwelling fatalities, calling it “missing in transparency” — hitting on one in every of Cuomo’s greatest controversies in the course of the well being disaster.
Whereas the pandemic overwhelmed the state’s well being and academic methods and introduced the enterprise and retail neighborhood to its knees, Cuomo didn’t assist issues, the report mentioned.
“The state didn’t think about the looks of impropriety associated to the way it was reporting COVID-19 nursing dwelling deaths till the general public was already upset, having observed and reported the discrepancies.”
Cuomo spokesman Wealthy Azzopardi defended his former boss in a press release Friday, saying the previous governor “introduced the unified pressure of presidency to bear” in the course of the lethal pandemic.
“His every day press briefings had been internationally acknowledged for offering the information amid a chaotic lack of a nationwide response to this pandemic the place 1.2 million Individuals misplaced their lives,” Azzopardi mentioned.
“Whereas this report cuts via the political rubbish that has consumed the nursing dwelling concern and factors out how circumstances had been constant nationwide, it’s ridiculous to counsel that this pandemic response be handled the identical as H1N1 or Legionnaires outbreaks,” he mentioned.
“The reality is within the numbers,” he added. “In 2020 New York was quantity 39 by way of professional rata nursing dwelling deaths, in response to federal stats, and and we went from having the second most deaths as a result of New York was hit first and hardest to thirtieth.”
The discharge of the report — which price $4.3 million — comes on the heels of Cuomo’s grilling by the Home Choose Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic, with the GOP majority on the panel accusing him of deflecting accountability for the order that shuffled sick sufferers into senior care services in 2020.
The report mentioned the scandal was part of “the theme of distrust” within the dealing with of the pandemic.
Nevertheless, Ken Girardin, director of analysis on the Empire Middle for Public Coverage, referred to as the Olson report “little greater than a highschool time period paper” in regards to the state’s dealing with of the COVID disaster.
“The largest price incurred by state authorities was the theft from the unemployment system,” Girardin mentioned. “There seems to have been zero investigation into the warning indicators and failures at NYS DOI.”
Requested in regards to the report at a briefing Friday. Gov. Kathy Hochul mentioned she had not but learn it however took her personal shot at Cuomo’s dealing with of the pandemic.
“We knew that issues needed to be performed in another way, they needed to be performed higher and we needed to put together for the chance that this is able to occur once more,” Hochul mentioned.
She mentioned steps have been taken to raised put together the state, together with a bump in funding for the state Workplace of Emergency Administration and a $1.7 billion funding in a brand new analysis lab.
Supply hyperlink
