A US healthcare government has sued John Oliver for defamation following a Final Week Tonight episode on Medicaid, during which the British-American comic quoted the physician as saying it was okay for a affected person with bowel points to be “a bit soiled for a few days”.
Dr Brian Morley, the ex-medical director of AmeriHealth Caritas, argues that Oliver – an outspoken comedian whose present has not solely addressed muzzling lawsuits however been topic to them – took the quote out of context in an April 2024 episode on Medicaid.
The swimsuit towards Oliver and Final Week Tonight producers Partially Necessary Productions seeks unspecified damages “in an quantity to be decided and in extra of $75,000”, in response to Deadline. It doesn’t title Final Week Tonight’s broadcaster, HBO.
The swimsuit, filed in New York final week, said: “Defendants falsely informed tens of millions of viewers of their present, Final Week Tonight with John Oliver, that Dr. Morley testified in a Medicaid listening to that ‘he thinks it’s okay if individuals have shit on them for days,’ deliberately main viewers to imagine that Dr. Morley made these alleged statements about – and illegally denied Medicaid providers to – a younger man who has extreme psychological impairment, was harnessed in a wheelchair, wears diapers, and required in-home bathing and diaper altering as a result of he may do neither himself.”
The swimsuit claims: “Defendants’ false accusations had been designed to spark outrage, they usually did. The false accusations Defendants made had been so heinous that John Oliver felt justified in telling his tens of millions of viewers: ‘fuck that physician with a rusty canoe. I hope he will get tetanus of the balls.’ Oliver’s feigned outrage at Dr. Morley was fabricated for rankings and earnings on the expense of Dr. Morley’s popularity and private well-being.”
The quote in query, which happens round 21 minutes into the episode’s 28 minute-long principal section, refers back to the story of Louis Facenda Jr, a quadriplegic with cerebral palsy whose in-home care program was disrupted following cuts to Iowa’s Medicaid providers.
Oliver cited an interview with Facenda and his mom and first caregiver, Joann, on the difficulties confronted by individuals with disabilities because the state shifted to for-profit “managed care organizations”, leaving Facenda spending hours in soiled diapers.
Oliver performed audio from Morley’s testimony at a 2017 administrative listening to, that aired as such: “Individuals have bowel actions daily the place they don’t fully clear themselves, and we don’t fuss over [them] an excessive amount of. Individuals are allowed to be soiled … You already know, I might permit him to be a bit soiled for a few days.”
Oliver stated of the snippet: “Look, I’ll be sincere, once I first heard that, I believed that needs to be taken out of context. There is no such thing as a means a physician, a licensed doctor, would testify in a listening to that he thinks it’s okay if individuals have shit on them for days. So, we obtained the total listening to, and I’m not going to play it for you, I’m simply going to let you know: he stated it, he meant it, and it made me wish to punch a gap within the wall.
“If I completely needed to put it into phrases, I assume I’d say fuck that physician with a rusty canoe, I hope he will get tetanus of the balls,” he continued. “And if he has an issue with my language there, I’d say I’m allowed to be soiled. Individuals are allowed to be a bit soiled generally, apparently that’s medical doctors fucking orders.”
Oliver additionally added that legally, he was required to say that AmeriHealth Caritas restored the affected person’s providers, however referred to as it a “shame” that it was disrupted within the first place.
The lawsuit argues that context minimize from the present adjustments the which means of Morley’s phrases, which they quote as thus: “In sure instances, sure, with the affected person with important comorbidities, you’ll wish to have somebody wiping them and getting the feces off. However like I stated, individuals have bowel actions daily the place they don’t fully clear themselves and we don’t fuss over an excessive amount of. Individuals are allowed to be soiled. It’s when the soiled and the feces and the urine intervene with, you understand, medical security, like in somebody who has concomitant comorbidities that you simply fear, however not on this particular case. I might permit him to be a bit soiled for a pair days.”
In accordance with the criticism, a senior Final Week Tonight producer spoke to Morley earlier than the episode aired and said that they’d listened to the total administrative listening to.
However “Defendants knowingly manipulated Dr. Morley’s testimony after which knowingly manipulated the context during which they positioned it such to convey the defamatory which means.”
Morley later “demanded that Defendants retract their False and Defamatory Statements”, which the present refused. The lawsuit additional claims: “Defendants printed the False and Defamatory Statements and Meanings with frequent legislation malice, with the intent to injure and reckless disregard for the rights of Dr. Morley.”
This isn’t the primary lawsuit confronted by Final Week Tonight.
In 2017, a West Virginia decide tossed a defamation swimsuit filed agains the comic and his present by Bob Murray, the CEO of a coal firm. The decide agreed with HBO’s argument that Oliver’s feedback had been both factual and sourced from varied court docket paperwork, or clearly satirical and thus protected by the primary modification.
Supply hyperlink
