On 8 March, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Ice) brokers arrested Mahmoud Khalil, a graduate scholar at Columbia College, as he was coming back from dinner together with his spouse in New York. The brokers mentioned the state division had revoked his scholar visa and inexperienced card, although he had by no means been accused of, not to mention convicted for, a criminal offense. He was held in detention in New Jersey, then transferred to Louisiana. He has nonetheless not been accused a criminal offense.
However, Donald Trump’s state division, headed by Marco Rubio, seeks to deport him below a provision of federal regulation that provides him the facility to deport somebody if their presence within the nation is deemed to “have doubtlessly critical opposed overseas coverage penalties for the US”. Khalil’s crime? He was a lead organizer of Columbia’s protests for Palestinian rights.
“Who has the proper to have rights? It’s actually not the people crowded into the cells right here,” Khalil, a Palestinian raised in exile in a Syrian refugee camp, wrote in a letter proclaiming his standing as a “political prisoner”. He’s the one of many most distinguished targets of a chilling federal crackdown over pro-Palestinian advocacy within the US, notably on faculty campuses. And he is without doubt one of the most forceful voices in The Encampments, a brand new documentary on the campus motion for Palestine that has drawn ire from throughout the US political spectrum, particularly the proper.
A sure characterization prevails in American mainstream media of the nationwide campus protests in 2024 in opposition to Israel’s bombing marketing campaign in Gaza: that the pro-Palestinian protesters had been violent, deranged, self-righteous, naive and antisemitic. That they peddled “radical, excessive ideology”, within the phrases of the speaker of the Home, Mike Johnson, and that they had been “disgusting cesspools of antisemitic hate, stuffed with pro-Hamas sympathizers, fanatics and freaks”, in response to Josh Hawley, a senator from Missouri.
The Encampments, directed by Kei Pritsker and Michael T Workman and distributed by the Palestinian-founded firm Watermelon Photos, places that narrative in stark reduction. Fees of terrorism, brainwashing and violence from sources as ideologically divergent as Fox Information and MSNBC overlay footage of scholars pitching tents, sitting collectively, taking part in music, chanting in communion and holding non secular observances. “The temper was so the other of what was being mentioned on TV,” mentioned Pritsker, who embedded in Columbia College’s 120-tent campus encampment in April 2024. “It was so humorous to open your cellphone up and watch some man in Washington DC say that there’s this den of antisemitism at Columbia’s campus, and also you’re watching a Passover Seder occur like 10 toes in entrance of you.”
The Encampments focuses particularly on Columbia, the point of interest of nationwide media curiosity over the protests and the inspiration for related pro-Palestinian encampments at universities across the globe. The Ivy League college has a storied historical past of activism, courting again via the civil rights motion of the Nineteen Sixties. It additionally has an undisclosed portion of its almost $14bn endowment invested in firms in enterprise with the Israeli army, which has killed 50,000 Palestinians and displaced 140,000 extra for the reason that 7 October 2023 Hamas terrorist assault that killed 1,200 Israelis and took 251 extra hostage. The scholars’ demand was simple: “We don’t need our cash to go in the direction of Palestinian dying,” says organizer and negotiator Sueda Polat within the movie.
The Encampments, which counts the rapper Macklemore amongst its government producers, begins with the occupation of the inexperienced on 17 April 2024 – an escalation, as Khalil, Polat and organizer Grant Miner clarify, solely after the college modified its protest bylaws and refused to acknowledge smaller-scale interruptions. The movie interweaves footage of the largely mundane, calm passing of the hours on the encampment with the destruction of Gaza – bombed hospitals, maimed youngsters, prolific and horrific dying – and archival footage of the college’s personal precedent for staging mass demonstrations for humanitarian causes.
Specifically, the 1968 occupation of Hamilton Corridor, during which college students demanded the college sever ties to the US conflict in Vietnam; in late April, the Palestinian protesters occupied the constructing with an identical demand. They renamed it Hind Corridor, in honor of a seven-year-old lady killed by the IDF after watching her total household shot (the movie contains her devastating cellphone name to emergency staff with subtitles, shortly earlier than she and the ambulance ferrying her had been bombed).
“College students have all the time been on the proper facet of historical past,” mentioned Pritsker, himself a former pro-Palestinian campus organizer. “College students protested the Vietnam conflict. They protested Jim Crow. They protested South African apartheid they usually protested the conflict in Iraq. College students weren’t unsuitable about any of these issues. And it’s ironic, as a result of Columbia celebrates that historical past.”
“A number of the largest protests in opposition to South African apartheid occurred at Columbia. A number of the largest protests for the civil rights motion occurred at Columbia,” he added. “And Columbia seems to be again on these moments and says, ‘Oh, take a look at how forward-thinking and progressive Columbia is. Take a look at how this occurred on our campus. We’re a pacesetter in historical past. Come to Columbia and you may be like these individuals.’ Effectively, that second is now.”
In 2024, as in 1968, the college resorted to calling the police when negotiations failed. The Encampments contains footage seen throughout the information final yr: officers capturing rubber bullets and teargas into demonstrations, dragging protesters throughout the road. Moreover, police doing nothing to cease counter-protesters who attacked encampments; at UCLA, some even threw lit fireworks at protesting college students.
“It was actually stunning to see so many campuses in the US was police states over this,” mentioned Pritsker of Columbia calling for the NYPD to finish the encampment, which precipitated police crackdowns throughout the nation. “We began the movie with a query: what was it a couple of bunch of scholars tenting out on lawns that was so incomprehensible, so impermissible to the politicians, to the media, to the ruling class of this nation, that they might relatively arrest college students, teargas them, handcuff them, than cease investing in firms which might be complicit in conflict crimes?”
These actions now embrace cooperating with the Trump administration to examine college students who’ve criticized Israel, aggressively self-discipline college students who interact in pro-Palestinian disruptions, and plan “complete” reform of the college’s admissions insurance policies, lest they lose out on $400m in federal funding. The movie ends with a haunting post-script because the crackdown begins: Khalil stays in detention; 5 days after his arrest, Miner was expelled, together with 22 different college students who had been concerned within the occupation of Hind Corridor. Some had their levels revoked.
At Columbia at present, “clearly there may be worry, however I feel greater than worry, there’s anger”, mentioned Pritsker. “Individuals are livid that their administration capitulated to the Trump administration’s calls for, completely chucking up the sponge, principally.”
Nonetheless, “loads of the scholars usually are not going to cease”, he added. “I don’t assume anybody concerned within the Palestinian motion signed up for the motion as a result of they thought it could make them extra protected or snug. I feel most of us understood that it could make us much less protected. It would truly pose dangers to our security, however none of that issues as a result of if none of us are protected – if somebody out there may be below the specter of being bombed or being shot at any second on any given day – then we’re all unsafe.”
Supply hyperlink
