What’s the view of US democracy from overseas, and what can People study from different nations with a historical past of political tumult?
Throughout his first time period Donald Trump examined democratic norms by undermining belief in honest elections, encouraging political violence and demonizing the media and public servants. He has promised to be a dictator “on day one” of his second time period.
As Trump is inaugurated for a second time, we requested political correspondents at newspapers world wide – from Hungary to El Salvador – to share their view of what’s taking place in America.
These are nations who’ve endured strongmen leaders and challenges to democracy. Do they see analogies with what is going on within the US right this moment – and in that case, what do they suppose the long run holds for the world’s strongest democracy?
András Pethő, Direkt36 (Hungary)
People ought to cease telling themselves “this will by no means occur right here”. You need to brace your self for the worst eventualities, as a result of something can occur.
Within the first couple of years of the Orbán regime, once they proposed curbing the powers of the constitutional court docket and so they appointed a member of Fidesz, Orbán’s get together, to the state audit workplace, which is essential in controlling how spending public cash is spent, I assumed: “This could by no means occur in a democracy.” After which we discovered that really something can occur, as a result of if they’ve the facility, they will and can [do] no matter they need.
All these establishments, whether or not we’re speaking about governments or businesses or the press, are very, very fragile. It’s very simple to dismantle them.
The American information media scene remains to be far more vibrant and strong than Hungary’s, so I feel it will be more durable for Trump or whoever, to take it over. In Hungary, a pro-government investor purchased up all of the native newspapers – there have been solely about 19 of them. That gained’t occur within the US, however in fact, a media crackdown or the unfold of propaganda can occur in numerous methods. It would occur by way of X or by way of Fb – that’s one thing that I’m listening to.
Glenda Gloria, Rappler (Philippines)
The marketing campaign and consequence was very very similar to our 2022 presidential election. Leni Robredo and Kamala Harris determined late within the day to run, however once they did they galvanized a democratic base that all of us thought had grown too cynical to be concerned in any election.
However the narratives of [Bongbong] Marcos and Trump have had a head-start on-line, spreading so exponentially and viciously that no quantity of groundwork may match them. Mix with a local weather of worry and you may bend something and anybody. We’ve seen that within the Duterte, years and we anticipate to see it – as we’re starting to – underneath Trump.
Individuals who have loads to lose and who as soon as valued due course of, freedom and accountability can simply do the bidding of authoritarian leaders. Establishments that when protected public curiosity can flip towards it straight away. America is in for a every day shock-to-the-system interval. We all know this from the Duterte years; the primary two years have been marked with disbelief – the every day assaults on media, the killings each night time, the harassment of huge enterprise, the co-optation of the police and the navy, the embrace of China regardless of intrusions into our territory. They appeared unreal.
Has our world gone mad? It has. We take a look at America now and joke: ought to we do workshops for our [journalism] colleagues? It’s totally unhappy.
We’re paying shut consideration to how disinformation, and the networks that maintain it, will proceed to prop up the Trump administration and Trumpism. That’s the stomach of the beast. As a result of even the worst insurance policies might be made proper in a world of manufactured realities. How ought to US residents counter or handle that? We have to floor real-world experiences and initiatives that illustrate good citizenship. Islands of hope.
Carlos Dada, El Faro (El Salvador)
In the event you can draw any conclusions about Mr Trump from his first time period, it’s apparent that he has little or no respect for establishments, and that his character has a unprecedented weight over the train of the presidency. I don’t see something that signifies his second time period will probably be totally different.
Within the case of El Salvador, Nayyib Bukele is precisely the type of chief that Mr Trump loves. Trump embraces autocrats and derides democratic leaders, and Bukele is an autocrat. World leaders within the type of Mr Bukele – I’m speaking about Orbán, Modi, Putin, in fact — will simply really feel far more snug of their dismantling of democracy with Mr Trump and the presidency.
For Mr Trump, moreover the private affinities that he might have with Mr. Bukele, his agenda for Central America is principally migration and safety. That’s it. The normal, submit cold-war US agenda, which had a robust emphasis on democracy and human rights, is gone.
So I feel so long as Mr Bukele is stopping migrants [from passing through El Salvador en route to the United States] and retains the gangs successfully dismembered, then Washington gained’t be an impediment for Mr Bukele in his means of utterly dismantling democracy and turning El Salvador into his personal dictatorship.
Vinod Okay Jose, former editor of the Caravan and creator of a forthcoming guide on Indian democracy (India)
Trump’s technique, like that of all strongmen autocrats, was to have interaction with voters on the stage of emotion, not cause, and fiction, not details. These are some guidelines within the playbook that autocratic leaders use on a regular basis to get to energy.
With Trump returning to White Home, we’re seeing a decisive second in historical past. The third anti-democracy wave is right here. The primary two anti-democracy waves being the victory of Mussolini within the Twenties and Hitler coming to energy within the Thirties culminating within the second world battle, and the second anti-democracy wave within the Sixties with the rise of navy juntas and the chilly battle bringing down elected governments. Now, with nations like India, Turkey and the Philippines already underneath anti-democracy forces, Trump’s victory empowers the palms of the autocrats world over.
Biden’s spell in workplace was the time given by the divine to systematically alter world historical past, [an opportunity] to look inward to see how Trumpism had a lot assist in 2016, [and to] repair the holes that drifted votes to Trump.
In that sense, the misplaced alternative of the Biden years are corresponding to the ten years that the Congress get together had in India between the 2 spells of the Hindu proper governments, Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s (1998 and 2004) and Narendra Modi, who got here to energy in 2014. The Congress get together got here to energy in 2004 and did nothing to deal with the bottom of the precise, or to win over the sympathetic fence-sitters, or to make cultural and social allies. The end result? Modi, a frontrunner who was much more radical than Vajpayee got here to energy, with extra standard assist. The ten invaluable years in historical past have been misplaced.
I worry that 10, 20 years from now, folks may flip again and say the Biden years didn’t obtain something to cease Trump from returning.
Fernando Peinado, El Pais and creator of Trumpistas: ¿Quién llevó a Trump al poder? (Spain)
Quite a lot of protection concerning the rise of Trump and the far proper elsewhere has centered on the economic system, however I’m wondering if we’re speaking sufficient about an enormous transformation that occurred within the final decade – the earthquake inside our media ecosystem.
In 2016, smartphones and social media performed an outsized position as in comparison with earlier elections. That accelerated every little thing. The information cycle changed into a information cyclone. That helped candidates who relied on viscerality.
Since that election we’ve seen wins by populists and far-right candidates elsewhere. In Spain, the far-right Vox emerged in 2018, having beforehand been very fringe. One thing deep has modified and maybe the US, and UK, with Brexit, have been simply two early examples of what was to return. The canaries within the coal mine.
This yr marks the fiftieth anniversary of [Francisco] Franco’s loss of life and the legacy of Franquismo is a really polarizing subject now. What’s new is how divisive the problem of Franco has turn into. For many years, there gave the impression to be a consensus that Francoism was a darkish interval for Spain. However now you’ve the [Conservative Partido Popular] unwilling to commemorate his loss of life, and Vox is making an outspoken protection of his legacy.
Their statements in assist of Franco haven’t broken their approval ranking, and that connects with all of the bizarre issues taking place within the US – Trump doing unprecedented issues that may have been taboo in a earlier period.
Responses have been edited and condensed
Supply hyperlink
