A Manhattan plastic surgeon reduce towards his mannequin ex-girlfriend’s explosive claims he turned her right into a “intercourse slave” and carried out a process with out anesthesia to cowl up his abuse.
Maya Willow Sias’ personal texts and Instagram posts disprove her bombshell accusations towards Fifth Avenue surgeon Ammar Mahmoud, his argued legal professionals in a courtroom submitting final week towards her $10 million lawsuit.
The 18-page reply contends Sias, 25, is a “manipulative girl with a observe file of alcohol-fueled violence and of threatening romantic companions with reporting false accusations of abuse.”
“She doesn’t inform the reality as a result of she is making an attempt to shake down Dr. Mahmoud for cash, as we detailed in our reply,” the physician’s lawyer Marc Kasowitz, a associate at Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP, informed The Submit.
Sias, in a lawsuit filed in Manhattan courtroom throughout October, contended Mahmoud had turned her right into a “intercourse slave” throughout a brief, abusive relationship with him.
The case was moved to federal courtroom in November.
Mahmoud had as soon as overwhelmed Sias so brutally that he shattered her eye socket — and had tried to cowl up his abuse by secretly taking her to his luxurious Alinea Medical Spa, the place he painfully injected fillers into her still-swollen face with out anesthetic, the bombshell go well with contended.
The lawsuit included images of Sias’ bruised and swollen face purportedly taken by the mannequin after the alleged June 7, 2023, assault by Mahmoud, wherein he was mentioned to have mercilessly punched and smothered her with a pillow after she awoke in the course of the night time to search out him partying with three prostitutes.
However Mahmoud’s attorneys preserve that Sias’ story of horrific abuse and sexual slavery is undercut by Instagram photographs and private texts along with her then-paramour.
The texts and pics present contemporaneous proof that Sias carried on a carefree, glamorous life through the time she alleged he horrifically abused and held her prisoner, in keeping with the brand new submitting.
Texts from early June 7, 2023, seem to indicate that Mahmoud and Sias had been at a nightclub till nearly 4 a.m. — and an Instagram publish from considered one of her buddies confirmed she had no accidents to her face, the submitting argues.
Different posts from later that day present Sias went to Lamia’s Fish Market with three buddies for a “ladies night time,” contradicting her assertion she went to dinner with Mahmoud, the papers contend.
“Extra considerably, on June 8, Ms. Sias posted an image of herself on Instagram which makes it obvious that the alleged June 7 assault couldn’t have occurred as alleged within the Grievance,” the submitting states.
The Submit couldn’t independently confirm if the photograph exhibiting Sias’ apparently unhurt face was taken after the alleged assault.
Sias contended after the alleged beating that Mahmoud successfully saved her prisoner in his condo for a month.
Within the submitting, Mahmoud’s attorneys contend that texts from June 8, 2023, confirmed she attended “three separate occasions that night and didn’t ask for his permission.”
The clandestine medical remedy Sias alleged Mahmoud performed on her battered face in late July 2023 is likewise undercut by an early August 2023 textual content she despatched to him that reveals it and her proper eye “to be in good situation,” the submitting contends.
The submitting presents different, typically graphic texts from Sias to Mahmoud that his legal professionals contend present that that they had a mutual and consensual relationship, slightly than the nightly forcible sexual assaults she claimed he subjected her to for months.
Mahmoud’s attorneys additionally declare that Sias finally left New York to not escape his abuse, however as a result of “he now not was prepared to pay for the entire luxuries she wished,” the submitting states.
Days after Sias left town, she grew to become “engaged to a unique, older, rich man – roughly 40 years her senior and now her husband” with whom she had an allegedly tumultuous relationship involving false accusations of abuse, the submitting contends.
Sias’ lawyer Larry Hutcher couldn’t be reached for remark.
The abuse accusations leveled by Sias in her lawsuit echoed related claims made by Mahmoud’s ex-wife in a long-running courtroom battle.
Supply hyperlink