A cab dispatcher died days after an enraged driver slugged him exterior a Midtown lodge final month – and the alleged attacker was reduce unfastened due to a authorized loophole, in line with cops and sources.
Efrain Patino Guerra, 53, was working at a cab stand exterior the Lodge Riu Plaza Manhattan Instances Sq. on West forty seventh Avenue close to Seventh Avenue round 1:15 p.m. on June 17 when motorist Jaime Rosario, 54, flew right into a rage, NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny advised reporters Tuesday.
As Guerra was assigning fares as lodge company walked out, he skipped one of many drivers, who went berserk and confronted the dispatcher, in line with Kenny.
“He’s very very a lot greater than Mr. Patino, and sooner or later, he sucker-punches him sq. within the face,” Kenny stated. “You may see from the video he’s clearly knocked unconscious — whereas he’s standing up, falls again and hits his head on the concrete.”
Patino Guerra was unable to maneuver till first responders rushed him to Bellevue Hospital, the place he was initially listed in important situation – and spent a while in a coma, in line with Kenny and a criticism filed in Manhattan Legal Court docket in opposition to Rosario.
Throughout his keep on the hospital, Patino Guerra went into cardiac arrest and was “sort of lifeless for about seven minutes,” earlier than he was revived, the police official stated.
He finally succumbed to his accidents on June 27, cops stated.
Three days earlier, the NYPD had busted Rosario and charged him with second-degree assault, in line with Kenny.
However that cost was downgraded in courtroom to third-degree assault, a misdemeanor – as a result of a felony rap requires intent to trigger critical bodily harm or the usage of a weapon, legislation enforcement sources stated.
Neither of these circumstances might be established, since Rosario allegedly dealt Patino Guerra a single blow to the face, in line with the sources.
Decide Jonathan Svetkey granted Rosario supervised launch, because the misdemeanor cost isn’t bail-eligible – and has not been because the statewide bail reforms enacted in 2020.
Rosario is subsequent scheduled to seem in courtroom on July 18, data present.
It remained unclear Wednesday whether or not Rosario might face upgraded prices because the investigation is ongoing.
In the same Brooklyn case again in March, a tow truck driver accused in a deadly assault on a 61-year-old man whose automobile he was impounding was reduce unfastened due to the identical loophole in so-called one-punch murder instances.
Kevon M. Johnson, 30, allegedly delivered a single punch that despatched Carlyle Thomas, 61, barreling into the pavement the place he fatally struck his head throughout an argument that broke out over a $10 parking spot at a Brownsville Shell gasoline station, authorities stated on the time.
Johnson was granted supervised launch at his arraignment on a cost of third-degree assault, prosecutors stated then.
“The legislation permits just for prices regarding the punch and there’s no approach to show intent to trigger his dying or some other critical harm,” a legislation enforcement supply advised The Publish of that case.
Supply hyperlink
