Man who spent years in jail for rape he didn’t commit cleared by attraction courtroom

Man who spent years in jail for rape he didn’t commit cleared by attraction courtroom


ndrew Malkinson, who served 17 years behind bars for a rape he didn’t commit, has been cleared by the Courtroom of Enchantment.

The 57-year-old was discovered responsible of raping a girl in Higher Manchester in 2003 and the next 12 months he was jailed for all times with a minimal time period of seven years.

However his conviction was quashed by senior judges on Wednesday, after DNA proof got here to gentle which linked one other potential suspect to the crime.

Overturning his convictions, for 2 counts of rape and certainly one of choking or strangling with intent to commit rape, Lord Justice Holroyde stated Mr Malkinson may “go away the courtroom free and not be topic to the situations of licence”.

On the time of Mr Malkinson’s trial, there was no DNA proof linking him to the crime and the prosecution case in opposition to him was primarily based solely on identification proof.

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) conceded that Mr Malkinson’s conviction was unsafe as a result of the brand new DNA proof factors to a different man, who the courtroom ordered can solely be recognized as Mr B, and stated there “should now be an actual chance” that man will probably be charged over the assault.

The CPS and Higher Manchester Police (GMP) confirmed in Might they’d not contest the attraction.

Lord Justice Holroyde stated different factors argued by Mr Malkinson’s authorized workforce, about “essential” materials that was not disclosed on the time of his trial, “raised plenty of substantial and essential factors” and the courtroom would take time to contemplate them and provides a choice on them later in writing.

He added: “Nonetheless, we should hold Mr Malkinson ready not to know the end result of his attraction.”

On the preliminary listening to in Might, Edward Henry KC, representing Mr Malkinson, informed the courtroom the Legal Circumstances Overview Fee (CCRC), which investigates attainable miscarriages of justice and referred Mr Malkinson’s case to the Courtroom of Enchantment, had been conscious since 2009 that there was “crime-specific” DNA which was not a match for both Mr Malkinson or the sufferer.

Nonetheless, he stated at the moment the CCRC “didn’t take into account it tipped the steadiness in direction of a referral” to the Courtroom of Enchantment.

In October final 12 months, the pattern was discovered to be a partial match for one more man, who the courtroom ordered can solely be recognized as Mr B.

Mr Malkinson beforehand utilized twice for his case to be reviewed by the CCRC however was turned down, finally being launched from jail in December 2020.

After his launch, developments in scientific strategies allowed his authorized workforce, supported by authorized charity Enchantment, to offer new DNA evaluation that forged doubt on his conviction to the CCRC.

The physique then commissioned its personal testing which discovered that DNA from the sufferer’s clothes matched one other man on the nationwide police database.

GMP confirmed in January {that a} man had been arrested and launched underneath investigation in gentle of the brand new info, however no resolution has been made as as to whether he will probably be charged.

Supply hyperlink