File income for grain companies amid meals disaster immediate requires windfall tax

File income for grain companies amid meals disaster immediate requires windfall tax

Firms on the centre of the worldwide grain commerce have loved a report bonanza amid hovering meals costs all over the world, elevating considerations of profiteering and hypothesis in international meals markets that would put staples past the attain of the poorest, and prompting requires a windfall tax.

The world’s prime 4 grain merchants, which have dominated the worldwide grain marketplace for a long time – have seen report or near-record income or gross sales. They’re forecasting demand to outstrip provide at the least till 2024, which is prone to result in even increased gross sales and income within the subsequent two years.

Meals costs have surged greater than 20% this yr, in accordance with the UN Meals and Agriculture Organisation. About 345 million persons are experiencing acute meals insecurity, in accordance with the World Meals Programme, in contrast with 135 million earlier than the Covid-19 pandemic.

Olivier De Schutter, a co-chair of IPES-Meals (the Worldwide Panel of Specialists on Sustainable Meals Methods) and UN particular rapporteur on excessive poverty and human rights, mentioned: “The truth that international commodity giants are making report income at a time when starvation is rising is clearly unjust, and is a horrible indictment of our meals programs. What’s even worse, these firms may have accomplished extra to forestall the starvation disaster within the first place.”


4 firms – the Archer-Daniels-Midland Firm, Bunge, Cargill and Louis Dreyfus, recognized collectively as ABCD – management an estimated 70-90% of the worldwide grain commerce. “International grain markets are much more concentrated than power markets and even much less clear, so there’s a large threat of profiteering,” mentioned De Schutter.

He mentioned this yr’s meals worth surge occurred regardless of what are regarded as considerable international grain reserves, however there was inadequate transparency from the businesses to indicate how a lot grain they maintain and no strategy to power them to launch shares in a well timed approach.

“We should be wanting on the grain giants and asking what they might have accomplished to avert the disaster, and what they might be doing now,” De Schutter mentioned.

Cargill reported a 23% enhance in revenues to a report $165bn (£140bn) for the yr ended 31 Could, whereas Archer-Daniels-Midland made the best income in its historical past in the course of the second quarter of the yr.

Gross sales at Bunge surged by 17% yr on yr within the second quarter, although its income had been affected by beforehand incurred expenses. Louis Dreyfus reported income for 2021 up by greater than 80% on the earlier yr, as revenues rose by practically 1 / 4 to $1.62bn.

John Rogers, an analyst on the credit standing service Moody’s, mentioned it was not shocking that offer constraints and rebounding demand had elevated meals costs and led to increased income. “I don’t suppose they’re colluding for outsize income,” he mentioned, including that many extra firms had been additionally taking an rising share of world grain markets. “I don’t suppose they’re performing immorally – they’re not deliberately driving up costs.”

A Cargill inland grain terminal close to Nesbitt in Manitoba, Canada. {Photograph}: Terrance Klassen/Alamy

He mentioned the income for grain firms had been rising general however their margins had not markedly elevated in proportion phrases. “This can be a comparatively environment friendly market – I don’t suppose these guys can ramp up the costs.”

Nonetheless, unpublished evaluation by an NGO, seen by the Guardian, suggests some meals firms could also be rising their margins too. The evaluation discovered Archers-Daniels-Midland elevated its revenue margin to 4.46% within the first quarter of this yr, up from 3.65% in the identical quarter in 2021, and Cargill’s margin elevated from 2.5% final yr to three.2% this yr.

Sandra Martinsone, a coverage supervisor at Bond, a community of worldwide growth charities, mentioned a windfall tax can be a strategy to restore some stability to meals markets and assist the poorest.

“[The big agrifood companies] are clearly capitalising on the lowered provide and elevated demand, additional exacerbated by commodity buying and selling,” she mentioned. “When provide is considerably decrease than demand, it provides house for worth enhance. However that is additionally exacerbated by speculative inventory markets, since wheat and different commodities are traded on inventory markets and due to this fact costs fluctuate.”

Oxfam has additionally referred to as for a windfall tax on meals firm income. Alex Maitland, a senior adviser on the charity, mentioned: “There are fears that hypothesis might be a driver in meals worth rises. Something that causes starvation and hunger is immoral.”

Natalie Bennett, a UK Inexperienced occasion peer, joined the decision. “As a short-term measure there are sturdy arguments for a windfall tax on the meals oligopoly – the handful of firms, with important cross-ownership from hedge funds, that from seeds to supermarkets are main contributors to the inflation that’s driving the price of dwelling disaster to new heights,” she mentioned.

Vicki Hird, the pinnacle of sustainable farming on the UK meals coalition Maintain, stopped wanting calling for a windfall tax as she mentioned it was onerous to separate out the value results in supermarkets the place customers purchase most of their meals. However she referred to as for the federal government to manage to cease abuse. “Whereas farmers, customers and meals staff are struggling within the face of spiralling meals and gasoline costs, these sitting in the course of the meals chain – a small variety of large, dominant grain merchants – are raking in huge income.”

If governments reject a windfall tax they need to contemplate different means to curb costs, mentioned Martinsone, together with worth caps or tighter regulation of commodity buying and selling, such because the ban on commodity buying and selling launched in India to restrict inflation and worth hikes. She mentioned meals firms and commodity speculators had been additionally blamed for fuelling the meals worth rises seen greater than a decade in the past, when surging costs led to riots in lots of nations.

The causes of the meals worth rises are advanced. The Ukraine battle has performed an enormous half as Ukraine is among the world’s prime producers of grain, sunflower oil, maize and fertiliser. The battle despatched meals costs hovering to their highest ever ranges in March, although some have fallen again barely since. A standoff with Russia over shifting grain shipments from Ukraine for export has been partially resolved and a few shipments have now moved, however harvests from Ukraine and Russia can be affected this yr and subsequent.

Rising power and fertiliser costs, which have additionally spiralled because of the invasion of Ukraine, have an effect, whereas the rebound in demand after Covid lockdowns has added additional strain.

Grain harvests in Europe, North America and India have additionally been affected by the local weather disaster. Final yr’s heatwaves in Canada damage wheat crop yields there, and excessive temperatures and wildfires this yr are prone to inflict injury.

This all provides as much as a rosy image for grain producers. Demand for his or her product is surging, provides are constrained, and regardless of rising enter costs within the type of power and fertiliser, their income look safe.

The Guardian contacted all 4 of the ABCD firms for remark however has not acquired replies.

De Schutter mentioned: “Finally, we have to break up the monopolies which have a stranglehold on the meals chain. A handful of firms management international seed and fertiliser markets, animal genetics, the worldwide grain commerce, and meals retail. They’re making large income at the price of farmers, customers and the atmosphere.”

Within the UK, meals costs have risen for a lot of staples, including to woes over power costs which might be set to prime £3,500 a yr this winter for the typical family. Poverty campaigners have warned persons are dealing with harsh selections this winter over whether or not to eat or warmth their properties.

Supply hyperlink