At the nook of Sundown and Hollywood Boulevards as soon as stood a monument to one of many best film flops of all time. A 300ft-high plasterboard Babylon, with partitions broad sufficient to shoot chariot races on, it was flanked by large white elephants (oh the symbolism!). Intolerance (1916), a three-and-a-half-hour silent film, carried out so catastrophically on the field workplace that its megalomaniac creator DW Griffiths couldn’t afford to demolish the set. For years it remained, crumbling, as a warning to Hollywood – “Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!”
Fortunately Hollywood didn’t give two hoots, as a result of in any other case we’d have missed out on Tim Robey’s erudite and brilliantly entertaining chronicle of film extra.
A movie author for greater than 20 years, Robey is aware of all too properly that “failure fascinates”. This, in any case, is a critic who awarded the notorious, eye-clawing abomination that’s Cats (2019) an unheard-of zero stars within the Day by day Telegraph, but confesses to then reserving a ticket to a “singalong” screening as a responsible pleasure.
Few issues are such a present to put in writing about as massive, gobbling turkeys, but Robey doesn’t let his choice of 26 juicy flops (one per chapter) baste themselves. He avoids apparent selections comparable to John Travolta’s Battlefield Earth, “an notorious bid to get Scientology out to the lots by means of the medium of a panto-shonky house opera”. As a substitute, he hunts out lesser-known clunkers comparable to A Sound of Thunder (2005), a barely seen, “below-the-radar bellyflop” that includes rampaging baboon-lizard hybrids that was bankrolled by Battlefield Earth’s producer, Elie Samaha, a former bouncer at Studio 54 turned “schmoozer extraordinaire” – one of many many bigger than life characters that populate this various historical past of the business.
As a result of that’s what Field Workplace Poison is. Sure, it’s a vibrant catalogue of catastrophe, chock-full of clashing egos, runaway budgets and acts of God. However what makes this a five-star e-book is the best way Robey weaves within the wider context so deftly that you simply barely discover. A chapter on nautical thriller Velocity 2: Cruise Management, for instance, (a “clattering shambles” that its personal star, Sandra Bullock, disowned as making “no sense. Sluggish boat. Slowly going in direction of an island”) illustrates the bruising strategy of blockbusters transitioning to CGI in the course of the late Nineteen Nineties. (Evaluating it with rival water-logged manufacturing Titanic, broadly predicted to be a $200m flop, is a reminder how shut successful can sail to catastrophe.)
But for all of the cogent evaluation, wry commentary and playful enjoyment of dysfunction, extra compelling is how deeply Robey cares about his misfit canon. You’d count on a cineaste to agonise over the misplaced 132-minute director’s lower of Orson Welles’ The Magnificent Ambersons, which was reshot, recut and launched in a butchered 88-minute model by RKO, earlier than it burned the negatives (then normal business apply). However he’s simply as impassioned in regards to the misunderstood deserves of Babe: Pig within the Metropolis, a family-unfriendly sequel a couple of speaking pig directed by Mad Max auteur George Miller, notable for its spine-tingling savagery. It unleashes a few of Robey’s best and funniest writing: I used to be laughing so onerous at his description of a pink poodle I needed to put the e-book down.
Like a film-nerd Indiana Jones, Robey generously excavates treasure from the trash. He even makes an attempt to rehabilitate Gigli (2003), the unpronounceready, smug, Bennifer love-in, claiming it hosts one in every of Jennifer Lopez’s “most interesting performances”. But some movies are so unhealthy they’re merely unhealthy.
Field Workplace Poison’s “stinkiest binbag” is reserved for The Adventures of Pluto Nash, the Eddie Murphy moon-based motion comedy so depressingly dire that even Robey can’t make it amusing or illuminating. In actual fact, you surprise why he bothered together with it; maybe for its staggering monetary loss. It value greater than $100m and grossed solely $7.1m, which was barely a 3rd of Murphy’s personal $20m charge.
Robey’s heroes are those that withstand their failures, comparable to Halle Berry, who gamely turned up in particular person to just accept her worst actress Golden Raspberry for Catwoman, rightly calling it “a bit of shit godawful film”. Or the Coen Brothers, who discovered that “the strained maximalism” of The Hudsucker Proxy, a flashy, hole $40m flop a couple of hula hoop salesman “taught them unignorable classes, which have been absorbed instantly”. They went on to make the grim and genuine Fargo for simply $7m, successful two Oscars.
As to the villains, Robey’s judgment falls heaviest on the “uncontrolled white male genius” administrators who bullishly steered their films in direction of their icebergs. And they’re all males, as a result of traditionally Hollywood by no means allowed ladies to play with big-boy budgets.
Robey is extra forgiving of his inventive favourites: Welles is indulgently dubbed a “runaway maestro”, whereas William Friedkin’s self-confessed “callous, self-involved” behaviour on Sorcerer doesn’t cease him from declaring the 1977 flop a “lethal masterwork”. However we’re inspired to shed no tears for Erich von Stroheim, a bully “who had a repute for assaulting his actresses”, or Tod Browning, a “bastard” and a “sadist” who by no means recovered from the reception given to Freaks (1932) and died an alcoholic recluse.
after e-newsletter promotion
What different classes may be gleaned from these cautionary tales? Properly, the outdated adage “by no means work with animals” nonetheless applies, be it the hormonal elephants that diminished the battle scenes of Intolerance to bedlam, the kittens that clawed a unadorned Seena Owen in Queen Kelly (1929), the sheep that repeatedly peed on Rex Harrison in 1967’s Physician Dolittle (whose shoot was halted for days after a giraffe stepped by itself penis) and of course, these creepy, digitally contoured, butthole‑much less Cats.
We additionally study that many movies we take into account legendary monetary failures truly weren’t: for instance Waterworld, Kevin Costner’s soggy $175m sci-fi in the end turned a revenue; that, for all of the knowledge of hindsight, flops can’t be predicted – as Robey factors out, again in 1997 it was Sorcerer, not Star Wars, that seemed like a positive factor, whereas in 2008, you’d have tipped Velocity Racer over Iron Man to be a field workplace smash; that we in the end study extra about how Hollywood works from its humungous losers than we do from its Oscar winners.
But having persuaded us that the medium of movie is richer for its missteps, Robey’s celebration strikes an elegiac notice. Studios, already diminished to “nervous unoriginality” following the 2008 monetary crash, are ever extra risk-averse within the wake of Covid. The rise of streaming offers a “handy burial floor” whose lack of measurable field workplace means a possible flop will go unrecorded. Soulless digital backlots have all however changed the old-school means of constructing blockbusters utilizing “sensible magic” (actual stunts, actual areas, every little thing achieved in-camera). Right now the white elephants of Intolerance would solely exist as pixels on a server marked for deletion. The period of the flop is fading to black and Robey mourns the loss.
“They already don’t make ’em like Cats any extra,” he concludes. His e-book is so wildly pleasing, it virtually makes me want they did.
Field Workplace Poison: Hollywood’s Story in a Century of Flops by Tim Robey is printed by Faber & Faber (£16.99). To help the Guardian and Observer, order your copy at guardianbookshop.com. Supply fees might apply.
Supply hyperlink