A federal choose likened DOGE efforts to determine and remove waste and fraud on the Social Safety Administration to a “fishing expedition” on Thursday, blocking Elon Musk’s workforce of cost-cutters from accessing the private data of Individuals held by the company.
District Decide Ellen Hollander’s momentary restraining order compels DOGE staffers to delete any personally identifiable knowledge they might have collected from SSA and any software program put in on the company.
The Maryland choose additionally informed senior SSA officers to stop Musk’s workforce from accessing any programs that will include personally identifiable data, resembling Social Safety numbers, medical data, banking data, revenue historical past and tax data.
Hollander, an appointee of former President Barack Obama, allowed SSA to supply DOGE with “redacted or anonymized knowledge” for the size of the 14-day restraining order.
The choose appeared skeptical of DOGE’s aim and want for such delicate knowledge.
“The American public might properly applaud and help the Trump Administration’s mission to root out fraud, waste, and bloat from federal companies, together with SSA, to the extent it exists. However, by what means and strategies?” Hollander wrote in her 134-page order.
“The DOGE Workforce is actually engaged in a fishing expedition at SSA, looking for a fraud epidemic, based mostly on little greater than suspicion,” she argued. “It has launched a seek for the proverbial needle within the haystack, with none concrete data that the needle is definitely within the haystack.”
Hollander mentioned the Trump administration “by no means recognized or articulated even a single cause for which the DOGE Workforce wants limitless entry to SSA’s whole file programs, thereby exposing private, confidential, delicate, and personal data that hundreds of thousands of Individuals entrusted to their authorities.”
She described DOGE’s strategies for uncovering potential waste, fraud and abuse as “hitting a fly with a sledgehammer.”
Within the lawsuit introduced by labor unions, the Trump administration revealed that of the 10-person DOGE workforce at SSA, seven had read-only entry to personally identifiable data.
The Trump administration argued that DOGE’s stage of entry wasn’t considerably totally different from different federal staff at SSA, who’re routinely allowed to look its databases.
The pinnacle of the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Workers – one of many unions that introduced the lawsuit in opposition to the Trump administration, celebrated the ruling Thursday.
“This can be a main win for working folks and retirees throughout the nation,” AFSCME President Lee Saunders mentioned in a press release. “The courtroom noticed that Elon Musk and his unqualified lackeys current a grave hazard to Social Safety and have illegally accessed the information of hundreds of thousands of Individuals.”
The previous performing head of SSA, Michelle King, resigned final month after reportedly taking subject with DOGE’s efforts to entry the company’s delicate databases.
King was changed by Leland Dudek, who has been supportive of DOGE’s mission, and has shuttered a number of places of work inside SSA, impacting a whole bunch of staff.
An SSA spokesperson informed The Submit that the company “will work to adjust to the courtroom order.”
Supply hyperlink
