Dehorning rhinos reduces poaching by 80%, examine finds

Chopping the horns off rhinos causes a big discount in poaching, in accordance with a brand new examine, which raises questions in regards to the effectiveness of pricey anti-poaching strategies used to guard the African mammals.

Poaching for horn is a major menace to the world’s 5 rhino species. The substance, which is analogous to human fingernails, is often used for conventional drugs in China, Vietnam and different Asian nations. Sellers within the hidden market can pay tens of hundreds of {dollars} for the horns, that are falsely believed to be efficient at treating fevers, ache and a low intercourse drive in conventional drugs.

However new analysis within the journal Science has highlighted methods to higher defend the animals from unlawful hunters. An evaluation of rhino safety strategies within the Better Kruger area of South Africa – dwelling to 1 / 4 of the continent’s rhinos – discovered that eradicating horns decreased poaching by almost 80% between 2017 and 2023.

In a collaboration between scientists, conservationists and authorities officers, the analysis discovered no statistical proof that conventional anti-poaching interventions – equivalent to rangers, detection cameras, canine monitoring and helicopters – brought about important reductions in rhino poaching, regardless of their multimillion-dollar value, though they had been profitable at detecting lots of of poachers.

“Dehorning rhinos to scale back incentives for poaching was discovered to realize a 78% discount in poaching utilizing simply 1.2% of the general rhino safety funds,” mentioned Dr Tim Kuiper of Nelson Mandela College, a lead writer of the examine. “We’d have to rethink our objectives. Can we simply wish to arrest poachers? It doesn’t look like making an enormous distinction to lowering rhino poaching.”

To dehorn a rhino, staff sedate the animal, apply a blindfold and earplugs, and minimize off the horn with an influence noticed. The horn will step by step regrow – a mean rhino must be dehorned each 1.5 to 2 years. The method poses a really low danger to the animal and doesn’t damage it.

“The headline result’s that dehorning stood out for its effectiveness. We’re cautious to say that the opposite interventions aren’t working. They labored when measured by whether or not they had been detecting poachers. However detecting and arresting a load of poachers doesn’t essentially bend the curve on rhino poaching,” Kuiper mentioned.

In South Africa, rhino poaching stays excessive, with 103 killed within the first three months of 2025. Final 12 months, 420 had been misplaced. In current many years, rhino populations have collapsed in Asia and Africa as a consequence of poaching and habitat loss, persevering with falls pushed by European colonial hunters.

However the researchers behind the challenge, representing the College of Cape City, Nelson Mandela College, College of Stellenbosch and the College of Oxford and different conservation establishments, cautioned that dehorning rhinos was not a magic bullet. A big stump of horn mass stays on the rhino after dehorning, and a few poachers had been nonetheless ready to kill rhinos for this part.

Sharon Haussmann, a pioneer in rhino conservation in South Africa and co-author on the paper, performed a number one function in coordinating conservation efforts within the examine space. She died unexpectedly at the weekend and Kuiper needed to focus on the collaboration between totally different sectors which can be usually mistrustful of one another in her reminiscence.

“Is a rhino nonetheless a rhino with out its horn? That’s a much bigger query,” mentioned Kuiper.

One examine of black rhinos indicated that whereas poaching charges decreased, dehorned animals turned extra timid and coated a lot smaller ranges. Researchers consider that horn is used to ascertain territories and dehorned rhinos had been unable to do that after the process.

“We wouldn’t prefer to maintain dehorning them for the following 100 years,” Kuiper mentioned. “Ideally we wish to handle the drivers of poaching. However it’s higher than the impacts of poaching”

Discover extra age of extinction protection right here, and comply with the biodiversity reporters Phoebe Weston and Patrick Greenfield within the Guardian app for extra nature protection